← Back to context

Comment by monooso

14 hours ago

> I want as basic a car as possible that goes forward when I press the gas and stops when I press the brakes.

GP was talking about HUD and "new features" in the context of a $60k car. Presumably your desired "basic car" would cost considerably less.

What "new features" are we talking about? What else do you need in a car? Do you complain about "new features" in an expensive bottle of whiskey? Or a nice computer? No, you want the basics done really well and made with the highest of quality.

  • When I went from a 2006 mini to a 2021 polestar 2, there were a bunch of things that were either "up in class" or "15 years makes things better" - traction control, non-invasive lane-assist (with invasive options), per-driver (per-keyfob really) seat adjustment memory, charge-aware navigation, radar cruise-control, 360° camera fusion, headlight washers, kick-to-open trunk, interior pre-warm (including seats, as a software upgrade), smart (camera-based) auto-dim of high beams, mirror-retract when parked, mirror tilt when backing up, retractable trailer hitch... little of this is structural, it's just an accumulation of details and attention paid to them.

    • And a few downgrades (if my 2023 Polestar 2 is an indication)

      * Wait 60 seconds to start using the GPS / nav to become responsive

      * Unreliable backup camera (even after several software "fixes")

      * No buttons or knobs for climate control

      * No way to disable intrusive line detection that makes car vibrate when you get close to yellow and white lines

      * Overzealous auto-dim of high beams (our 2023 Mazda CX-5 is significantly better with almost no false positives)

      It's not all bad, and once the infotainment warms up, it's plenty responsive. It's certainly a luxury car though (as an admitted Mazda fan) you can get a lot of nice from a $30k Mazda.