Comment by lotsofpulp
1 month ago
> but the central point is that people who have to USE their insurance (i.e. sick people) subsidize the premiums of people who don't (healthy people), and this critique applies regardless of age.
You’re losing me here. This claim is categorically false. You cannot consider only the deductible when calculating who subsidizes who.
The only way to calculate it is premiums + deductible + out of pocket maximum = total healthcare costs. And the subsidy via premium is so large that it negates effects of a deductible and out of pocket maximum.
Note that all plans have to be actuarially equivalent, regardless of what deductible you choose. The actuaries have to account for rebates and other pricing strategies when ensuring actuarial equivalence, so that the ratio of what the plan pays versus what you pay meets the required ratio for that metal level.
https://www.healthcare.gov/choose-a-plan/plans-categories/
Since your health is not a factor in pricing your insurance, it has to be that people less likely to need healthcare pay for the people likely to need healthcare.
It is the same as if the government forbade auto insurers from using moving violations history, or life insurers from using health measures, or home insurers from using flood maps.
The claim about who subsidizes who was always hyperbole, I'll grant you that. I included the statement to make the point that this is the phenomenon people are referring to when they make that statement.
I happen to think there is validity to the statement if you control for other actuarial factors. But if you don't think that makes sense as a lens through which to look at the problem, I won't quibble, even though I disagree. We're also only talking about drug prices here, which is a small portion of overall healthcare spending.
In any case, the central point, that insurers benefit from higher prices, still stands.
> In any case, the central point, that insurers benefit from higher prices, still stands.
All sellers benefit from higher prices. No one limits the price they ask for out of the goodness of their hearts. Lower prices are because a competitor offers a lower price, and because buyers can’t pay a higher price.