← Back to context

Comment by nomilk

5 days ago

Video explaining the situation:

https://www.tiktok.com/@jasonkpargin/video/75915920529540252...

For context, Jason Pargin is an American novelist: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jason_Pargin

Deleting his life’s work, his imagination, extension of his brain and all the rest.

He’s not wrong to say all of those.

>https://www.tiktok.com/@jasonkpargin/video/75915920529540252...

That video is really confusing. It makes a few claims:

1. turning off onedrive backup deletes local files from your computer

2. there's no way delete files on onedrive without jumping through a bunch of hoops or losing your local copy

3. onedrive sucks because the file is only temporarily kept locally, and if for whatever reason it gets corrupted on microsoft servers, you're out of luck.

Is there confirmation for #1? That's really the only point that seems relevant to the claim of "onedrive just deleted my files", but I'm skeptical that onedrive is that bad, and the fact that he brought up the other two points (#2 specifically) makes me think what might have happened was that he deleted files on onedrive to free up space on his microsoft account, not knowing that it would also delete the local copy. The latter is still bad, but is at least somewhat defensible because that's how services like dropbox work. Also, if it's really #2, shouldn't the files be recoverable because onedrive has a recycle bin?

The level of entitlement and irresponsibility tech companies (especially the largest and most well-resourced ones) is just astounding. You'd think that proper engineering requires some degree of care and stewardship, but these aren't engineering organizations, they're toddlers.

OK, but this is possible only if you give in and create a Microsoft account, right? If you don't do it and only use a local account, they will be unable to do any of these shenanigans because they will have no account to upload the files to, right?

  • Windows 11 is forcing you to create and sign into a Microsoft Account, which will also pretty much auto enable all cloud based services connected to that account if you are not careful enough and/or do not really understand what you are doing (= someone without any IT experience).