← Back to context

Comment by CastIron888

5 days ago

Not old enough?

How about a steam engine with the front axle bolted to the boiler?

A steam boiler is subject to considerable stresses already and adding dynamic forces to the shell can't be a good idea?

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/4/42/Kemna_ro...

Heh, that's not a monocoque, but it's definitely directly bolting the engine to one suspension component. WJW. We've come so far.

  • You can see in the picture the boiler is taking the load of the machine. There is no additional chassis.

    That's less frame than a Ducati has between the front and rear wheels.

    Without speaking to the wisdom of stressing batteries mechanically, the idea of using drivetrain components as structural members of a vehicle is as old as self-propelled vehicles.

    Hell, even a chariot sees the horse taking a part of the vehicle load.

    • Merely "using drivetrain components as structural members" is not a monocoque, but it's a start.

      You're correct on the chariot.

      A monocoque incorporates ALL components as stressed members so even a classic Lotus Esprit would fail that strict definition given that both hood and trunk are free-floating cantilevers, but point taken.

      1 reply →