Comment by dghlsakjg
3 days ago
That’s a take!
The modern world would collapse in about a week if banks were not allowed to loan out deposits.
The ability to satisfy needs now and pay for them in the future is why you can have a house, why governments can build infrastructure, etc. That’s the only reason that banks really exist. Keeping your deposit safe for you while providing convenient access via cards, checks and other rails is just a wonderful side effect.
After a few thousand years of civilization we don’t have anything better that could allow you to satisfy current needs with future income. Direct loans are just vendors acting as de facto banks, at much higher risk.
A bank product that doesn’t loan out your deposits is called a safe deposit box. There’s your solution.
> The ability to satisfy needs now and pay for them in the future is why you can have a house
The housing market has been greatly influenced by the ability to loan vast sums for housing, and without that we would have a very different housing market but we would still have one.
I think banks should lend but it's probably fair that we have controls on lending, and I think we should probably tighten them up especially around housing.
Housing loans have been exceptionally tight since 2008. That's why the market collapsed for a while.