← Back to context

Comment by tombert

2 days ago

> 3. We need to protect our IP. Then release it under a copyleft license.

No affiliation with Kagi, but I think you're dreaming if this actually would make a difference.

How many times has GPL'd software successfully been argued in court? Maybe four or five? Considering how many millions of software packages exist and how hard it would be to prove enough to bring a lawsuit/discovery request, I would be extremely surprised if there aren't thousands of GPL violations out in the wild that never go to court. I remember the source code to Spongebob Squarepants Supersponge violated the GPL [1], and that wasn't discovered for decades.

I am mostly ok with FOSS, and I don't love the idea of using a fully proprietary browser either, and I am probably not going to use Orion on Linux, but I don't think it's inherently wrong for them to want to keep any secret sauce close to their chest.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20129285