← Back to context

Comment by mapontosevenths

1 day ago

The last time this subject came up someone in the thread jumped up to explain to me how Windows 11 has all these great new features that make it worth being many times less performant.

Every feature they listed was some anti-consumer thing that only a corporate customer would ever care about or want. Every single one.

What I learned is that Windows 11 is great for the customer, I'm just not the customer. I'm just the dummy who paid for it.

12 comments

mapontosevenths

Reply
greenavocado  1 day ago

- TPM 2.0 requirement

- Secure Boot enforcement

- Microsoft account requirement

- BitLocker device encryption tied to MS account

- Hardware attestation

- Telemetry/Data Collection

- Extensive diagnostic data collection

- Advertising ID tracking

- Activity history syncing

- Bing integration everywhere

- Edge as persistent default (difficult to change) - OneDrive integration/nagging

- Microsoft 365 upselling

- Copilot integration

- Widgets panel with MSN content

- Start menu web search forcing Bing

- Centered taskbar (not moveable)

- Simplified right-click menu (hiding options)

- Removed taskbar features (no drag-to-taskbar, no ungrouping)

- Start menu ads/recommendations Update Control

- Forced automatic updates

- Limited update deferral for Home users

- Feature updates bundled with security updates

- Device Management (Enterprise)

- Intune/MDM integration

- Windows Autopilot

- Azure AD requirements

- Remote wipe capabilities

- Monetization

- Ads in Start menu

- Ads in File Explorer

- Suggested apps

- Pre-installed third-party apps (Candy Crush, etc.)

  • ewoodrich  21 hours ago

    FYI, nearly all of that UI/app garbage can be removed (or re-enabled like the Start/context menu) in <5 minutes with:

    https://github.com/Raphire/Win11Debloat

    It persists across updates, can be customized with extremely granular control over what is removed/re-enabled, or using the default mode which works fantastically for most users with minimal risk of disabling something many people might prefer to keep (e.g Xbox app).

    I’ve been using it for years on every machine/VM with Windows 11 installed. The OS gets out of my way completely both in terms of functionality and distractions like ads.

    I cannot recommend it enough, I am eternally grateful to the maintainers for making Windows 11 feel like a modernized Windows 7 experience.

  • t0bia_s  20 hours ago

    Most of it are turned off or possible to turn off in LTSC IoT version, which is only Win version reasonable to use without beenig annoyed when using it.

  • gruez  20 hours ago

    This list really needs proofreading.

    >- BitLocker device encryption tied to MS account

    Unless something changed with 11, this is opt in, with a specific "save to your microsoft account option". I really don't see the issue here.

    >- Hardware attestation

    This is either a rehash of the "TPM 2.0 requirement" point above, or just outright false.

    >- Telemetry/Data Collection

    >- Extensive diagnostic data collection

    This are the same thing restated

    >- Forced automatic updates

    >- Limited update deferral for Home users

    Again, these are just the same thing.

    >- Feature updates bundled with security updates

    That's basically... every commercial OS out there? Good luck getting security updates on android (if your OEM even provides it) if you're not on the latest version. Some linux distros even have it as a selling point, aka. rolling release.

    >- Device Management (Enterprise)

    >- Intune/MDM integration

    These are the same thing AND you have to jump through hoops to enable it. I really don't see the issue here.

    >- Copilot integration

    >- Windows Autopilot

    You can just... not use it?

    >- Azure AD requirements

    ???

    Is this just restating the microsoft account requirement?

    >Monetization

    This is a restatement for half the other points.

    >- Start menu ads/recommendations Update Control

    >- Ads in Start menu

    >- Suggested apps

    >- Pre-installed third-party apps (Candy Crush, etc.)

    All stating the same thing.

    • davkan  19 hours ago

      To be fair, while many of those are indeed optional or non-issues, the problem is that user experience has been degraded in w11 while there has been almost zero value-add for end users.