← Back to context

Comment by dangoodmanUT

6 hours ago

But it’s not theft, because you’re not redistributing. It’s allowed, just like humans are allowed to learn from copyrighted content.

Sure. But if I see listen to some song, and copy it, and release it, I could get sued. Even if I claim that I'm merely inspired by the original content - the court doesn't care.

You don't need to redistribute the original material, it's enough that you just copied it.

  • > But if I see listen to some song, and copy it, and release it, I could get sued.

    This is what should be fixed in the first place, then. You shouldn't get sued from what you do with your copy of a song.

> just like humans are allowed to learn from copyrighted content

humans learning : machines learning == whale swimming : submarine swimming

It's not the exact 100% same thing. Therefore you cannot base any rights on it.

If you still don't buy it, consider this analogy:

killing a human vs. destroying a machine

Thank god that we're not using your line of thinking here.