← Back to context

Comment by thethirdone

1 day ago

Which ones of those have been achieved in your opinion?

I think the arbitrary proofs from mathematical literature is probably the most solved one. Research into IMO problems, and Lean formalization work have been pretty successful.

Then, probably reading a novel and answering questions is the next most successful.

Reliably constructing 10k bug free lines is probably the least successful. AI tends to produce more bugs than human programmers and I have yet to meet a programmer who can reliably produce less than 1 bug per 10k lines.

Formalizing an arbitrary proof is incredibly hard. For one thing, you need to make sure that you've got at least a correct formal statement for all the prereqs you're relying on, or the whole thing becomes pointless. Many areas of math ouside of the very "cleanest" fields (meaning e.g. algebra, logic, combinatorics etc.) have not seen much success in formalizing existing theory developments.

> Reliably constructing 10k bug free lines is probably the least successful.

You imperatively need to try Claude Code, because it absolutely does that.

  • I have seen many people try to use Claude Code and get LOTS of bugs. Show me any > 10k project you have made with it and I will put the effort in to find one bug free of charge.