Comment by bicepjai

I think the author slips into the same pattern he’s criticizing. He says LLM fans shouldn’t label skeptics as “afraid” then he turns around and labels the fans as “insecure” or “not very good at programming.” It’s the same move; guessing what’s going on in someone’s head instead of sticking to what actually happened and what the tools can or can’t do. The simpler truth is LLMs are great in some cases and painful in others. They shine on boilerplate and tests. They struggle when the domain is unusual, requirements are fuzzy; mistakes are made, you pay a big babysitting tax.

Instead of psychoanalyzing each other, people should share concrete examples