← Back to context

Comment by andoando

10 days ago

Same, you wouldn't criticize a woodworking forum for not having politics.

I would, if people on that woodworking forum did critical work for DOGE, or Palantir, or Facebook, or Sam Altman.

  • Most of us don't work at those places.

    And besides, what does discussing technology itself have anything to do with it? If you work at big tech you're not allowed to particpate in tech forum as a hobby?

    We already discuss politics here as it has to do with tech (privacy is a pretty common topic here for example).

    • >Most of us don't work at those places.

      Right, but we should be able to shame, ostracize, and criticize the people that do work at those places because if we don't then it's a tacit approval of what they do.

      You know that saying about how if you have three people sharing a bench with a Nazi, you actually have four Nazis? Tech has social and political ramifications, the discussion of which is artificially suppressed on HN.

      Most of the time you can't do that here. Try saying something negative about Sam Altman, for example. dang has certain topics he just won't permit and then hides behind the excuse of "if everyone is upset with you, you must be doing something right".

      >If you work at big tech you're not allowed to particpate in tech forum as a hobby?

      I don't understand what you mean, can you please clarify?

      2 replies →

Oh, so we can peacefully ask for some advice from the guy that says "I'm proud to have made the wooden doors in Auschwitz" ?