Comment by realusername
7 hours ago
I've been there since the early days of React and I haven't seen a single React codebase which isn't a pile of duck-taped random packages, often leading to poor user performance.
Maybe it can be done, maybe not, but the average front-end dev doesn't have the insights to fill the gaps that React has left.
Some codebases are better than others, more mature open-source projects tend to be more polished, closed enterprisey things can be nightmare fuel, but that’s all probably universal to a degree and not specific to whether you’re using React or not. (OK, dependency mess is at least somewhat specific to JS.)
My real development experience started with Django—arguably one of the best-documented proper frameworks out there even before it reached 1.x—and let me tell you: the kind of garbage I have seen once I started doing it professionally still makes me shudder[0].
I agree with you in the sense that the choice to forgo a framework and use only a bunch of libraries directly should be very carefully considered. Frameworks exist for a reason. The decision should be made with the full understanding that one would implicitly undertake a task to create a framework (even if it is a narrowly specialised one just for that project). A lot of what you do if you go with raw React will not actually be front-end development: prepare to be vetting dependencies for (or implementing yourself) very basic functionality, fighting bundlers, trying to get TS to use correct global typings for the context, managing version hell to get all of the above to interoperate, etc.
(By the way, any mistake you make will be on you. Picked a test runner that was discontinued? Some transitive dependency got hijacked? There is no one else to blame. There’s no BDFL and expert core dev team vetting things, knowing when and how to write from scratch if there’s no trustworthy third-party implementation, orchestrating working version combinations, or writing migration guides.)
[0] Indeed it would be hubris to claim I myself have never ever architected something I would later call a monster held together with bits of duct tape.