Comment by the_af
14 hours ago
I get what you're saying but I think it's wrong (I also think it's wrong when people say "well, people used to complain about calculators...").
An LLM chatbot is not like querying a database. Postgres doesn't have a human-like interface. Querying SQL is highly technical, when you get nonsensical results out of it (which is most often than not) you immediately suspect the JOIN you wrote or whatever. There's no "confident vibe" in results spat out by the DB engine.
Interacting with a chat bot is highly non-technical. The chat bot seems to many people like a highly competent person-like robot that knows everything, and it knows it with a high degree of confidence too.
So it makes sense to talk about "hallucinations", even though it's a flawed analogy.
I think the mistake people make when interacting with LLMs is similar to what they do when they read/watch the news: "well, they said so on the news, so it must be true."
No, it does not. It's like saying 'I talk to angels' because you hear voices in the humming from the ventilation.
It's precisely like a database. You might think the query interface is special, but that's all it is and if you let it fool you, fine, go ahead, keep it public that you do.