← Back to context

Comment by hvb2

1 month ago

The insurance part will settle out over time as they get more data I would imagine.

500$ a year is very little for any car, but I opened a Nissan leaf for 8 years and spent less that 2K, of which 1K was for the AC

> The insurance part will settle out over time as they get more data I would imagine.

I'm not so sure. The issue is two-fold: First, If you get into an accident and you're at fault, the average damage is a lot more than with an ICE, due to the much heavier weight. Second, compared to an ICE, just about any repair is a lot more expensive. If some of the battery gets damaged, that's crazy expensive. There's also not a good ecosystem for parts - they are more expensive and less modular than with an ICE (or so I'm told).

It apparently is a lot more common for EVs to be declared a total loss compared to an ICE just because of the expense to repair.

> 500$ a year is very little for any car

This is over 3 different cars. And all of them very old (I bought two of them when they were 8 years old, and another when it was 15 years old - still driving that last one).

About $80/year for oil changes. That's it. Then every once in a while there is an expensive repair (brakes, tires, some engine problem, etc). Doesn't happen every year - so the average comes out to $500.

I also don't go to the official dealers. Everything is more expensive with them.

And yeah, the cars are old, so few electronic parts to repair. I imagine if I get another 8 year old ICE, the annual cost to repair will be more just due to the extra safety systems that can go wrong.

> but I opened a Nissan leaf for 8 years and spent less that 2K, of which 1K was for the AC

Leafs are the best case scenario. They're small, not heavy, and thus don't have much tire wear.