← Back to context

Comment by schiffern

11 hours ago

Scientific Reports is a junk journal fyi. Not conclusive, but indicative.

Despite saying the visible flux component is "small" and that the tungsten lamps "were not expected to [be used] as task lamps," Figure 6 (a) and (c) shows... desk lamps right at the work stations like task lamps! Not only is this experimentally unblinded, but the visible light immediately in front of the test subjects is noticeably brighter and warmer. The effect could simply be due to reduced eye strain.

What would James Randi do? "Extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof," and unfortunately this isn't it.

This would be more interesting if they add a visible light filter on the lamps so they only emit infrared radiation, and have an identical double-blind control with a 60 watt heater bulb so it emits no SWIR but the same radiant heat (which could confound and/or unblind).