← Back to context

Comment by tokyobreakfast

5 hours ago

This is sarcasm, right?

Absolutely not sarcasm. Control Panel is a mess and keeping it is only confusing for most users.

  • Literally every time I interact with the modern settings UI I give up 15 seconds in and switch back to the old control panel.

    For instance, how do you change the key repeat delay in the modern UI? I have looked and I actually can't find a way to change it. I have to use control panel.

    Just looking at the modern UI is an eyesore, there is so much empty space, a menu that should be a 600x400 rectangle takes up the entire screen. The information density is comically low. I have to scroll up and down this giant monitor sized list to find the one thing I am looking for. It's horrendous.

    • 90% of the time when you do find what you're looking for in Settings it's a hyperlink to Control Panel anyway.

  • I am confused by what you mean by this. An average user would interact with the new "Settings" and never really touch or see Control Panel...

    • Because many settings still aren't available in the "Settings" app, you often have to dig into the Control Panel (most notably for power options). Microsoft support forums and ChatGPT, which I think would be used by non-technical users when they encounter an issue, seem to both default to recommending going straight to the Control Panel to change settings.

  • No, Control Panel works as well as it did 30 years ago.

    Settings is a slow, bloated mess, as you stated elsewhere missing many settings, and was in general designed by schizophrenics.

    A primary reason for the sorry state of software today is the absolutely delusional priority that software should be "pretty" vs it being functional.

    Send all the UI/UX wizards packing, give them a Starbucks apron where IMO they belong, and watch software usability and customer satisfaction improve over the next 5 years.