← Back to context

Comment by JohnMakin

20 hours ago

Personally I believe this but it gets into conspiracy theory real quick. There are far simpler explanations.

Same, I want to believe that this is all a ruse and that the are smart and just really good at playing dumb, but there are just too MANY of them.

It's sycophancy plain and simple. Surround yourself with only yes-men, it ends up becoming less and less competent as the ones who stand up and say no are replaced.

Even if they know better, they can't do better because they know there is no loyalty to nay-sayers.

  • The main thing is that if you're a big enough entity, in favorable enough conditions, it's possible to make stupid decisions continuously and survive them for a very long time.

    It's the "market can remain irrational..." problem.

    • And as a consequence, never recognize them as being stupid---in fact the reverse, because your bad ideas are met with macro success even while individually they may struggle.

      It's yet another broken feedback loop.

The simpler explanation is that all the competent people saw what happened the first go around and want nothing to do with it. That leaves a detritus of sociopathic wannabes to select from for staff, all vying to mirror the behavioral profile of dear leader.

Incompetence and conspiracies go hand-in-hand.

  • Not really. It is far easier to explain incompetence in powerful positions than to explain competence on purpose in powerful positions - the latter is definitely a conspiracy, the former is not.

    • This administration’s incompetence allows their opponents to conspire much more effectively.

    • Quite often it is both.

      It's not uncommon for incompetent people to be put in positions of power. Because they are incompetent, competent but malicious people take advantage of this and commit actual crimes.

      This is where actual conspiracies show up. And that is the incompetent powerful people cover up said crime to avoid looking incompetent.

      It is an extremely common pattern.

      4 replies →