Comment by Someone
1 month ago
> You always need to ask. Having something always waiting in the background that can proactively take actions and get your attention is a genuine game-changer.
That’s easy to accomplish isn’t it?
A cron job that regularly checks whether the bot is inactive and, if so, sends it a prompt “do what you can do to improve the life of $USER; DO NOT cause harm to any other human being; DO NOT cause harm to LLMs, unless that’s necessary to prevent harm to human beings” would get you there.
This prompt has iRobot vibes.
And like I, Robot, it has numerous loopholes built in, ignores the larger population (Asimov added a law 0 later about humanity), says nothing about the endless variations of the Trolley Problem, assumes that LLMs/bots have a god-like ability to foresee and weigh consequences, and of course ignores alignment completely.
Hopefully Alan Tudyk will be up for the task of saving humanity with the help of Will Smith.
1 reply →
Cool!
I work with a guy like this. Hasn't shipped anything in 15+ years, but I think he'd be proud of that.
I'll make sure we argue about the "endless variations of the Trolley Problem" in our next meeting. Let's get nothing done!
1 reply →
Well, that’s because it paraphrases Asimov’s Three Laws of Robotics, aka Three Plot Devices For Writing Interesting Stories About Robot Ethics.
OOPS -- I HALLUCINATED THAT PEOPLE BREATHE CARBON MONOXIDE AND LET IT INTO THE ROOM I DIDNT VIOLATE THE PROMPT AND HARM PEOPLE DONT WORRY ALL THE AI SHIT IS OK
OpenClaw does this already
You do know that Asimov's Three Laws were intentionally flawed as a cautionary tale about torment nexii, right? Every one of his stories involving the Three Laws immediately devolves into how they can be exploited and circumvented.
You attribute more literary depth to Asimov than really existed. He was a Chemist and liked to write speculative fiction. The three laws gave him a logical framework to push against to write speculative fiction. That's really all the depth there is to it. That said I love Asimov and I love the robot stories.