← Back to context

Comment by parineum

13 hours ago

> mass human displacement campaign (a.k.a. Genocide)

genocide /jĕn′ə-sīd″/ noun

    The systematic and widespread extermination or attempted extermination of a national, racial, religious, or ethnic group. The systematic killing of a racial or cultural group.

Great, I’m glad your dictionary is happy about deporting 5 year olds.

“Uhm aktually it’s not a genocide it’s just a fascist police state”

Multiple humanitarian organizations define mass displacement as genocide and/or ethnic cleansing.

The holocaust literally started with mass deportations/detentions. Then the nazis figured out that it was easier to kill detainees.

  • If you have some point to make about deporting 5 years olds or whatever, don't you think it would be more persuasive without provoking a tangential discussion about your idiosyncratic definition of genocide regardless of whatever organizations agree with you?

  • > Multiple humanitarian organizations define mass displacement as genocide and/or ethnic cleansing.

    You're mixing two things here to your advantage. Genocide is (or can be) ethnic cleansing but ethnic cleansing is not genocide. So your "and/or" does some work for you there and makes you correct. However, you said genocide not "genocide and/or ethnic cleansing". You've moved the goalposts.

    It'd be odd to redefine any word that ends in '-cide' from actual killing.

    > The holocaust literally started with mass deportations/detentions.

    Which was ethnic cleansing.

    > Then the nazis figured out that it was easier to kill detainees.

    Which was the point which it became a genocide.