Comment by bjackman
15 hours ago
Getting Google Docs to be a Word alternative was an order of magnitude easier than getting GCP to be an AWS competitor.
Now that AWS has two serious competitors (and some non serious ones), privately funding another one just seems impossible to me. Who is gonna chip in tens of billions of dollars to fund "that, but European, and 15 years from now"?
I think the only ways we can get serious Euroclouds is some combination of:
1. EU intervention (nasty regulations and expensive subsidies).
2. People using non-equivalent products (Europeans have to use lower-level infra and do a lot more ops in-house). This part would have its upsides anyway TBH.
> I think the only ways we can get serious Euroclouds is some combination of
Just mandate EU countries' public administration to rely exclusively on EU cloud solutions. That doesn't need to be done at once.
This would create enough of a captive market to start the homegrown industry.
> Europeans have to use lower-level infra and do a lot more ops in-house
To be honest, every large enough company would benefit from doing a little bit of that.
> Just mandate EU countries' public administration to rely exclusively on EU cloud solutions.
This happens already in some areas and it is not cheaper or better. The EU funds national clouds where public institutions use them. What does it mean? VMware with Tanzu or OpenStack. And then some services thrown in to offer some S3 like buckets and that's it. The rest has to be built by the beneficiaries. Servers? Brand names like Lenovo/HP/Dell. Storage? Brand names like NetApp, HP, Dell, Lenovo, 3Par, IBM and the list goes on. Networking? Cisco (mostly), HP/Juniper. Firewalls? Cisco/Fortinet/PaloAlto/CheckPoint/etc.
Basically an enterprise setup masquerading as a cloud offering.
And even if there would be EU wide offerings for such cloud, there's too much money at stake to let institutions from one country buy services from another.
And it's all basically US tech made in China. The irony.
> Who is gonna chip in tens of billions of dollars to fund "that, but European, and 15 years from now"?
Dieter Schwarz might. At least he has the money and is trying 'something' with stackit. But he probably won't see the result in 15 years.