Comment by nindalf
13 hours ago
This reads like a nothingburger. Couple of quotes from the article:
> the idea that WhatsApp can selectively and retroactively access the content of [end-to-end encrypted] individual chats is a mathematical impossibility
> Steven Murdoch, professor of security engineering at UCL, said the lawsuit was “a bit strange”. “It seems to be going mostly on whistleblowers, and we don’t know much about them or their credibility,” he said. “I would be very surprised if what they are claiming is actually true.”
No one apart from the firm filing the lawsuit is actually supporting this claim. A lot of people in this thread seem very confident that it's true, and I'm not sure what precisely makes them so confident.
I find this wording also "a bit strange".
It is not a mathematical impossibility in any way.
For example they might be able to read the backups, the keys might be somehow (accidentaly or not) leaked...
And then the part about Telegram not having end2end encryption? What's this all about?
Telegram defaults to not e2ee; you have to initiate a "secret" chat to get e2ee.