Comment by Someone1234
5 days ago
3rd Party Keyboards exist, but they don't have the same rights/abilities as Apple's native keyboard, directly resulting in some features/functions being impossible to implement.
5 days ago
3rd Party Keyboards exist, but they don't have the same rights/abilities as Apple's native keyboard, directly resulting in some features/functions being impossible to implement.
Interesting (I am Android user myself). Any examples of such features?
- Apple's keyboard has richer context; third-party keyboards are largely limited to the text proxy (surrounding text/selection) and cannot inspect the host app/see the underlying context of where the text is used/what for.
- No caret/cursor control; cannot reliably set the cursor to arbitrary positions
- No custom dictation pipeline inside the keyboard; must rely on system dictation (or move voice input outside the keyboard).
- No camera access from the keyboard extension; blocks scan-to-type (OCR), QR/barcode capture, etc.
- Can do basic text expansions, but cannot implement privileged automation/macros that interact with other apps/UI or run broadly in the background.
- Due to aggressive lifecycle + tight resource limits constrain large language models/dictionaries; cloud sync/personalization
The ability to auto-fill the text/email verification codes is a huge one.