← Back to context

Comment by quotemstr

4 days ago

Again this word "feels". Is it not just nostalgia?

No. Good TUI apps are predictable and fast, like good native GUI apps. They follow set patterns. Familiarity and following standard conventions is not just "nostalgia" -- maybe a little is in there -- but it makes apps more usable. And, for cross-platform apps, it's a cross-platform standard. I'd rather have a TUI app following TUI conventions than a cross-platform app that is just a freeform mish-mash. Like, this week I've been making a TUI replacement for Plexamp which has great features but its Mac app is just like a scrolling webpage. If I am going to have a GUI app that is more than a tiny toy or utility I want it to follow each platform's native conventions and use its native GUI components or to not even bother. I will grant that Electron has made strides in terms of properly integrating into each host OS (using the full Mac menu bar, the correct keyboard shortcuts, accessibility features and so on) so the situation is not as bad as it once was. And also, plenty of people use and have used terminal editors and other tools by choice, for years, and not just because they are connecting to remote servers. A keyboard-first interface can be quite fast and they are more natural in TUIs.