← Back to context

Comment by dgxyz

10 days ago

[flagged]

Well, let's say this is the world view of all companies about open-source software. Then what happens. If people "tend to not give crap" about licenses, all the nice guarantees of GPL etc also disappear.

  • Very weird comparison.

    GPL was made in response to restrictive commercial licensing. Yes is uses the same legal document (a license): but is made in response!

    So is propriety seizes to exist, then it's not a problem GPL also seizes to exist.

    Also: it's quite obvious to me that IP-law nowadays too much. It may have been a good idea at first, but now it's a monster (and people seem to die because of it: Aaron Swartz and Suchir Balaji come to mind).

  • There are zero guarantees and commercial software uses GPLd software as parts of their products all the time. Licenses do not work and you shouldn't respect them whenever you can.