Comment by TensorToad
3 days ago
This is actually pretty exciting. Excited to see how this turns out. But I am wondering how to keep it financially possible to operate the platform. Also, 95+% of the users probably don't care that much about censorship and privacy enough to switch platform.
I would have thought that the point of federation is not to require centralized servers that cost a lot to operate.
But sure, something like this probably requires a fundamentally different revenue model. Maybe even the one where people donate to server operators.
centralized servers cost less to operate, that why data intensive applications centralize over time. That's division of labor. The higher the complexity the the higher degree of specialization. And a video service is very demanding.
And you need to solve the economics first because otherwise your decentralized service is simply going to centralize over time to deal with demands for a more reliable and higher quality service. (and how to compensate creators)
This so much, the Tiktok clones in ATProto face this same issue and several rely on Bluesky CDN & VC funding to have an acceptable UX (in terms of just delivering video content)