Comment by trinsic2
3 days ago
That same argument doesn't hold water on the internet. Its a communication medium. Its like a flow of information. You don't enter or leave physically spaces. the information flows to you where ever you are. trying to apply the same kinds of laws to the internet is a recipe for disaster because you are effecting everyone at the same time.
Yes, afaik authentication is performed by applications at L7 and as such flows via Internet protocols like anything else.
All kinds of laws are applied to services provided via Internet. For example, once upon a time people said collecting sales tax was an insurmountable problem and a disaster for ecommerce. Time passes and what do you know, people figured out ways to comply with laws.
Your example focused on time and place because taxes are done at a transactional level between the person purchasing goods online and receiving those goods in physically.
Age gating is not the same thing, there is no transfer of goods. It's someone's arbitrary idea of what should and shouldn't be allowed on the internet. And it's pretty clear at this point that it's about control over information. Plenty of articles on the subject if you care to look.
Taxes also apply to services and information, not just goods. I just checked some invoices to double-check my recollection.
You have made a claim that age gating some online services is an "arbitrary idea." I don't see how that is different from taxes at all. Taxes are likewise an "arbitrary idea." Taxes are likewise a societal control measure.
There is no need for articles to explain a very straightforward truth. If you are unable to make the case for something, claiming unspecified writings elsewhere doesn't get you any further.
2 replies →