Comment by ianm218
13 hours ago
This was my initial understanding but if you want ai agents to do complex multi step workflows I.e. making data pipelines they just do so much better with MCP.
After I got the MCP working my case the performance difference was dramatic
Yeah this is just straight up nonsense.
Its ability to shuffle around data and use bash and do so in interesting ways far outstrips its ability to deal with MCPs.
Also remember to properly name your cli tools and add a `use <mytool> --help for doing x` in your AGENTS.md, but that is all you need.
Maybe you're stuck on some bloated frontend harness?
I have never had a problem using cli tools intead of mcp. If you add a little list of the available tools to the context it's nearly the same thing, though with added benefits of e.g. being able to chain multiple together in one tool call
Not doubting you just sharing my experience - was able to get dramatically better experience for multi step workflows that involve feedback from SQL compilers with MCP. Probably the right harness to get the same performance with the right tools around the API calls but was easier to stop fighting it for me
Did you test actually having command line tools that give you the same interface as the MCP's? Because that is what generally what people are recommending as the alternative. Not letting the agent grapple with <random tool> that is returning poorly structured data.
If you option is to have a "compileSQL" MCP tool, and a "compileSQL" CLI tool, that that both return the same data as JSON, the agent will know how to e.g. chain jq, head, grep to extract a subset from the latter in one step, but will need multiple steps with the MCP tool.
The effect compounds. E.g. let's say you have a "generateQuery" tool vs CLI. In the CLI case, you might get it piping the output from one through assorted operations and then straight into the other. I'm sure the agents will eventually support creating pipelines of MCP tools as well, but you can get those benefits today if you have the agents write CLI's instead of bothering with MCP servers.
I've for that matter had to replace MCP servers with scripts that Claude one-shot because the MCP servers lacked functionality... It's much more flexible.