← Back to context

Comment by AndrewKemendo

9 hours ago

“There was a time when nobody trusted either aircraft nor elevators. Today people have pure unquestioned faith in both. Existential faith in fact, they test their faith with their lives. You may chuckle and laugh but that's simply because you are ignorant of the systems that keep you alive and safe”

https://kemendo.com/Faith.html

" Today people have pure unquestioned faith in both"

Not true at all. We accept the risks to obtain benefits but we also know having an accident in the air or in elevators is highly unlikely given what we know; so therefore its perfectly rational behaviour.

  • Nonsense

    that would assume that your average person has any concept of the relative statistics and has a sense of making decisions based on statistics

    People make decisions based on what other people around them are doing

    this is well known in safety engineering in architecture and civil engineering which is why you have standards for egress doors because left of their own devices humans will follow crowds to their own death

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crowd_collapses_and_crushes

    https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2008/05/080512172901.h...

    • One does not need to know of relative statistics to know that a) you dont see planes randomly dropping out of the sky on a regular basis b) people enjoy flying to hot destinations and are willing to accept the small chance the flight may not be risk-free - people are aware of this when they experience some level of turbulence when flying.

      Finally, Ive seen plenty of your posts on here. You write with a particular tone. Who are you? A nobody who's spent a lot of time posting crap on here.

      1 reply →

Elevators are suspended in a way that holds brakes open, if all of the multiply-redundant cabling snaps, the breaks activate. There's an airbag equivalent at the bottom of the shaft, too.

I don't really have a point I just think the typical elevator braking failsafe is so genius in its simplicity that I got excited to share.