Comment by 0x457
9 hours ago
In "proper" TDD you you supposed go:
- write a test for method that does not exist, it just calls the method and nothing else
- write method that does nothing
- add/extend test that uses that method <-- this very loop starts
- modify method until tests passes
- go back to loop start until you're done
I always hated it. When I work with LLM i first massage interface that tests, then tests, then implementation until all these tests pass.
> for example when it re-outputs the complete file when you ask for a tiny change).
well with sonnet 3.5 and 4.5 (can't say about 4.6) it often will get stuck in a loop trying to update just the required parts and iether waste tons of tokens doing these updates or waste tons of tokens to a point where restring file from git is required. Tokens get wasted regardless.
I like tests, but I don't bother with TDD because it's so ceremonial. I design the API, or at least sketch it out (using a whiteboard or drafting some notes, and doing research). Then I iterate and refine. I only bother with tests once I can commit or when it's no longer viable to tests manually (edit-compile-run cycle). And a lot of time I follow the table pattern.
https://www.oreilly.com/library/view/simplicity/979888865170...