← Back to context

Comment by getnormality

8 hours ago

So are you saying that bad programmers play a dual role of attending meetings to get business requirements, in a way that AI cannot do?

4 comments

getnormality

Reply
iugtmkbdfil834  8 hours ago

I am saying, having seen stuff implemented that simply does not make sense to anyone with an understanding of the actual situation on the ground, yes. And the funny thing is, it is not even an llm issue. This is a very, very human issue.

  • getnormality  8 hours ago

    So is the actual work of programming is mostly just sitting in meetings where business people and programmers slowly muddle through requirements?

    • iugtmkbdfil834  8 hours ago

      The actual work happens in the head. I suspect you know this. Now, there is a clear benefit to being able to flatten some of the issues related to coding, but do you really think, any of it can be done without those meetings and muddling through those requirements? At the very least, there needs to be one person that understands what is actually needed.

      I mean.. I am ok with you saying saying yes. In a sense, I half expect it. I will be very subtle, I don't believe the issue lies with the tooling ( AI or not ).

      1 reply →