Comment by thot_experiment
9 hours ago
Why is this a meaningful distinction to you? What does "reason" mean here? Can we construct a test that cleanly splits what humans do from what LLMs do?
9 hours ago
Why is this a meaningful distinction to you? What does "reason" mean here? Can we construct a test that cleanly splits what humans do from what LLMs do?
Sure, things like counting the ‘r’s in strawberry, for example (till they are retrained not to make that mistake).
There are humans that can't do that but are clearly capable of reasoning. Not a meaningful categorical split.
There are certainly humans with poor reasoning or even incapable of reasoning, I’m not sure what you think that proves?
1 reply →