← Back to context

Comment by _heimdall

10 hours ago

I can't imagine countries with such strict speech laws, for example, would be willing to build a system that is technically incapable of linking the person visiting a sire and the site requesting verification.

This proposal may have been updated since I read it previously, so I could be wrong now, but it didn't read as a true zero-knowledge proof as key steps in the flow still required a level of trusting the government as the central authority to do the right thing and not track requests, both today and in the future.

Seems like anywhere in the EU, something draconian only needs to be popular for like 5 years for it to get implemented, for better or for worse. They don't have robust constitutions like the US.

  • I wish the US constitution was robust, or at least could be held to such robustness today. As it stands congress has ceded much of their power to the executive branch and the public is barely represented when rules/regulations/laws are passed.

> I can't imagine

That's admirably honest, but the contents of your mind don't necessarily correspond to the world outside it.

The EU has more freedom of speech than the US, the US has just a different way of punishment.

It’s much easier in the US to lose your job for what you say as in the EU and in the US the consequences of losing your job are more severe if you don’t have enough money so you can afford to lose it.

US freedom of speech comes with a price tag that puts the censor inside your brain.

  • This is really an example of "formal rights and material conditions."

    You make a case that EU has better social safety nets and employee protection not that the US has weaker free speech laws. While you can't ignore the effect having wealth can insulate you from consequences, it still doesn't support your statement as written.

    Is it true that someone who is retired on a pension in US can say more hateful things without government action vs a similar retiree in EU?

  • And in the eu you go to jail for criticing politicians. I guess it's really all the same, eh?

    • You surely can provide a source.

      But even prisoners get healthcare in the EU, so I guess some US citizens would even prefer a EU jail over dying in the US.

      Given the recent deaths of two actors and their GoFundMes I can’t imagine the hassle of less fortunate people when they get hit by US medical bills.

      The US are one step away from a show like the Running Man shows