← Back to context

Comment by bojan

15 hours ago

Why not both? Encourage cycling when possible, and when not, an EV.

Looking at American commute distances however, cycling, even with an e-bike, is likely not a reasonable option.

Of course, both are better.

A lot of Americans probably won't be able to commute on a bicycle, but could easily use one for shorter trips like visiting friends, doing groceries, getting a burger, etc.

Even with commutes, there are lots that could be done on a bicycle. I briefly lived in the US and had a 6-mile (~10 km) commute. It was an unpleasant experience because there was exactly zero cycling infrastructure along the way, but otherwise it was a brief 25-minute trip, shorter than any of the commutes I've had in Europe. Not a single one of my American colleagues, all of whom lived locally, cycled or took a bus.

The issue is not just commute distances, it is cultural. Just in my personal "click" there are 5 people of which:

- 2 live less than 5 minutes from a metro that literally takes them to the office, they never take the metro

- 2 live easily within a biking distance to work, 1 has a bike, another has e-bike, they never bike to work

- 1 lives literally walking distance to work, she never walks to work

Public transportation where I live is vast, you can easily commute with the public transportation to just about everywhere but only low(er) income people will take public transportation.

Two most-frequently cited reasons I hear why not bike/walk/...

1. Dangerous - every female friend I have lists this as #1 reason they always drive. Regardless of the fact that I live in the area where I often forget to close my garage overnight and leave the front door open (very very low crime rates) the women feel unsafe. A lot of sensationalism in the news regarding every minor thing happening might be to blame but I have a wife and a daughter and am godfather to several girls so I understand

2. Inconvenient - what if after work I want to go to ____ and ____ and ____. Now I got to track back home and then perhaps change clothes, clean the house... and then get into the car to go to _____.