← Back to context

Comment by mbix77

3 months ago

What did measures like gdpr ever achieve except for making me click a cookie prompt away.

Right to be forgotten - you can ask companies to delete data they hold on you.

Data ownership/portability : you can ask companies for a copy of all data they hold on you or related to you.

I’ve seen the latter used by job applicants to get an entire copy of their interviews, transcripts and assessments including the reason for not being hired.

It makes you aware a site is selling your data or is otherwise tracking you because otherwise they would not need a banner to request for consents to do so :)

It's really a wonder how every time gdpr is even remotely related, there's always gotta be someone complaining about how gdpr is at fault for the cookie/data prompts, and never that sites and advertising companies (and their 2137 partners) are at fault for actually making those prompts as annoying as possible in hopes that you just agree.

Since people still seem to conflate the two, let me say it loud and clear:

GDPR HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH THE COOKIE PROMPTS!

GDPR doesn't apply in the states, but hopefully it provides for some punishment for the poor security here for EU customers. Of course, then some Americans will get mad that a US company has to follow EU law.

  • > Of course, then some Americans will get mad that a US company has to follow EU law.

    This is always the way of the world though, if you want to do business anywhere, you are of course obligated to follow the local laws and regulations. I don't see anyone disputing this outside of blatant patent infringement by certain countries.

  • The GDPR applies worldwide to any data held about EU or UK citizens, regardless of where they reside. It does apply in the US, it's just potentially harder for the EU to enforce meaningful penalties for infractions.