← Back to context

Comment by smcin

9 hours ago

To correct the mangling of history, there was no "list of Jews kept by the Netherlands [pre-occupation]". There were only pre-existing Dutch population registries of all people, where the personal details collected by the Dutch had included religion, not for any ill purpose.

(The Nazis subsequently compiled a list, post-occupation, but that's not what you asserted.)

So, the Netherlands kept a list of everyone, and they specifically marked out all the Jews, but that doesn't constitute keeping a list of Jews?

  • It wasn't a list of Jews, it was a list of everyone from which Jews could be easily identified.

    The distinction is important in this context, since the purpose of collecting and keeping the data wasn't specifically to have a list of Jews handy.

    This is relevant to data collected by companies and governments today.

    Consider a list of children with their parent names and the parents' preferred pronouns. You don't have a list of gays, but you have a list from which gays can be readily identified with high accuracy.