Comment by stavros
6 hours ago
Saying things like "there's no proof of your work" is the anti-LLM axe. Yes, it's all written by LLMs, and yes, it's all my work. Judge it on what it does and how well it works, not on whether the code looks like the code you would have written.
Is it your work? What did you bring to the table? Because if we're going to analyze design, then code is one function of that design.
For example, you talk about how the code is secure. How do you prove that it is secure?
The same way you prove your OSS code is secure.
People here see an LLM-assisted project and suddenly they've never written a bug in their life.
I cannot empirically prove that my OS is secure, because I haven't written it. I trust that the maintainers of my OS have done their due diligence in ensuring it is secure, because they take ownership over their work.
But when I write software, critical software that sits on a customer's device, I take ownership over the areas of code that I've written, because I can know what I've written. They may contain bugs or issues that I may need to fix, but at the time I can know that I tried to apply the best practices I was aware of.
So if I ask you the same thing, do you know if your software is secure? What architecture prevents someone from exfiltrating all of the account data from pine town? What best practices are applied here?
3 replies →
You're missing the point. I don't care who wrote it, I want to know if it works.
Also, you didn't address my remarks about your clock. Can you can show me a picture of it working in action?
But you didn't say anything about wanting to know how it works, your comment was:
> The article's content doesn't match his apps quality. They don't bring any value. His clock looks completely AI generated.
I don't understand your point about proof. After more than 120 open-source projects, you think I'm lying about the fact that my clock works? All the tens of projects I've written up on my site over decades, you latch on to the one I haven't published yet as some sort of proof that I'm lying? I really don't understand what your point is.
Here: https://immich.home.stavros.io/share/_k403I3s3cON-8oL5yP_QXY...