← Back to context

Comment by closewith

1 day ago

> Cars kill more than guns.

In most countries, but not in the US.

Just some context because gun violence studies are probably the most manipulated data sets in history. The two numbers (auto deaths and gun deaths) are pretty close to each other and different policies can and do push one above the other.

- Most of those gun deaths are suicides and the vast majority would happen anyway without guns.

- This wasn't true before about 2015 and the change (increase in non-suicide gun deaths) over the last decade is largely the consequence of 'defund the police' policies.

- 90+% of gun violence happens in about 4 urban zip codes, all of which have some of the strictest gun control laws in the US.

There is a reason you have never heard a criminologist rail about guns (its usually a sociologist). The data points to problems with other policies. Also gathering the data honestly is difficult; people stop reporting types of crimes when the police stop investigating those types of crimes.

PS A "curve-off" public welfare policy is far more effective than banning guns.

  • Not to get into a gunfight in the gambling hall, but:

    > Most of those gun deaths are suicides and the vast majority would happen anyway without guns.

    Apparently any form of obstacle between a suicidal person and their gun greatly reduces successful suicides.

    Things like the gun being in a safe that McSuicidepants owns, operates, and can get in with a fingerprint. Things like the bullets being on the other side of the room.

  • Americans desperately trying to justify their firearm fetish is embarrassing.

    > PS A "curve-off" public welfare policy is far more effective than banning guns.

    Roll eyes emoji.