← Back to context

Comment by energy123

5 hours ago

The energy transition in Germany sucks because they are replacing nuclear with solar when they should have been replacing coal with solar.

That doesn't mean renewables are bad, it just means that turning off already built nuclear plants is bad... Which is an entirely different matter.

If you look at China, they are building so much more solar than they are building nuclear, and they have no anti-nuclear sentiment. Their technocrats have decided, correctly, that solar is cheaper and better at current market prices.

for them prices are kinda similar. Their npp is 2.5bn/unit. But inland construction is banned.

Theyre replacing both with solar.

Germany never had a huge amount of nuclear power anyway and keeping it going was expensive. Fukushima was just what pushed them over the edge.

Meanwhile in the UK rate payers are being forced to subsidize nuclear power with a guaranteed strike price that is ~4x what they have to pay for the same amount of power from solar and wind.

Remove the lavish subsidies and make nuclear pay for its own catastrophe insurance and it'd be dead in the water. Those subsidies would be put to far better use on storage, wind and solar.