← Back to context

Comment by alexpotato

4 hours ago

> I asked if what they had done was ethical—if making deep learning cheaper and more accessible would enable new forms of spam and propaganda.

Someone asked Yuval Noah Harari, author of Sapiens, his thoughts on LLMs and how easy it was to create fake news, ai slop etc.

His response:

"People creating fake stories is nothing new. It's been going on for centuries. Humans have always dealt with it the same way: by creating institutions that they trust to only deliver factual information"

This could be government departments, newspapers, non-profits etc.

A personal note on this:

There is a Christmas card my grandfather made in the 1950s by "photoshopping" (by hand, not the software) images of each member of the family so it looked like they were all miniature versions of themselves standing on various parts of the fireplace. The world didn't collapse due to fake media between the 1950s and today due to people having that ability.

I see this kind of take a lot, and I don't think it's convincing. To me it's similar to saying that the water frame and the power loom won't change anything, because people have been able to make thread and cloth for millenia.

Individuals with Photoshop making obvious fictions for entertainment is different from funded entities producing clips at scale and passed off as real.