Comment by aftbit

We have a hard division between "Core" repos (those which are deployed to production / customer sites) and everything else. The expectation in Core repos is that everything goes through a PR process where the pull request message is intended to explain the what and why of the change (perhaps with reference to a ticket, but with the key information restated in the PR), and goes through a review just like the code. Changes are then either squashed with that as the commit message or (if they're larger and benefit from a clear separation of commits), may be rebased with `git rebase -i` assuming the final PR body ends up in one of the commit messages.

Non-Core repos are absolute free-form anything goes. You can commit 8 times a day without a PR as long as you're not deploying to production. This is excellent for things like test harnesses, CI/CD nonsense, one-off experiments, demos, prototypes, etc.

My last Core commit had something like 20 to 1 ratio between lines of commit message to lines of code (small change touching something deep that required a lot of explanation). My last non-Core commit message was "hope this works" (it did not).