← Back to context

Comment by rickdeckard

19 hours ago

Well yes, agree, but as stated Chrome didn't end up with this behavior because they did something, the Browser behaves like this because they didn't implement any logic for this permission.

A standardized attribute on an HTML-form would be difficult to define, because in this context the page just requests/receives a binary file, so a generic "strip embedded location information" decision from the user would be hard to enforce and uphold (also, by whom?).

In this case Android only knows the file-structure and EXIF because the file is requested by Chrome from a Media Library in the OS, not a file-manager.

W3C keeps thinking about this data-minimization topic repeatedly [0], so far they managed to define the principles [1], but enforcing them technically is quite hard if any kind of content can be submitted from a storage to a webpage...

[0] https://www.w3.org/blog/2019/adding-another-permission/

[1] https://www.w3.org/TR/security-privacy-questionnaire/#data-m...