Comment by eterm
5 days ago
I am weirded out but this, I find it horrific, like some kind of mind zombie, leeching humanity from your family members.
Someone somewhere is thinking they're connecting with you and sharing their humanity but they're just shoveling their soul into a machine that is "meticulously documenting" them.
Sorry, but ick.
To give a different perspective: archival is important. If nobody does this job, generational knowledge is lost at some point.
I talked plenty with my grandpa, but I'm sure he didn't even tell me 20% of his life.
And my other grandpa died when I was still a kid, so I didn't even get to have adult conversations with him.
Imagine making this available to your grandgrandgrandson.
Yeah, but you're kaoD. You're a bonafide person. You should talk with other people; it's good. (We're chatting right now.)
That's quite different from chatting with a bot that pretends to be human. (Do you want to chat with my bot?)
Yes. And I will die along with the memories from my grandpa. Most of them died already with him, and I don't remember all our conversations.
I have no kids but, even if I did, let's say I'd pass 20% of the 20% he passed on to me, and they pass 20% of the 20% of the 20%... You get the idea.
Heck, I already forgot 50% of my life since I don't have a journal!
This is not an "either" situation. Archival is important.
People write memories for a reason. This is automating the process, not superseding human communication.
I am the sort of person that never took photos (live in the moment yadda yadda). 15 years later, I'm starting to regret it.
Why does it have to be black and white? Why can't a bot do the exploration and notetaking along with people in the channel?
3 replies →
Btw my family know they are talking to the bot and they know that the bot is taking notes for our benefit. And I am in the channel and I enjoy reading those stories myself and would have never thought to ask those questions myself. Sometimes I ask the follow up questions myself too...
Well that makes it a lot less bad, it sounded from your post like it messages on your behalf and as you.
If it identifies as a bot then I find it a lot less objectionable.
I still wouldn't do it myself, but I can put the pitchfork down.
hi, cool use-case! Question: do they have to type it, or one can upload an audio (old people such as me may talk for 5mins about a mini-story vs typing for 20mins, especially if they use a phone vs windows telegram application (typing on a keyboard vs the smartphone). in which case, do you got a STT 'module' that will pick up the audio, transcribe it, and then 'process' it?
I actually think this is cool. How is this different than sitting people down with a camera every day and asking for a new random story? we won't be around forever and documenting it is one way to keep memories alive in people's minds
I was surprised myself how engaged my family have been with the bot. And equipped with the knowledge of our family history, it is able to ask deeply informed follow up questions! I would recommend trying it!
Would you feel differently if it was an app that sent notifications every day to people to document their thoughts/memories?
I think the ick factor you are feeling is from anthromorphizing a computer program by thinking its a "mind zombie".
You are making a lot of assumptions.
I hope OP is using some self-hosted local model to document their family archives
This is actually a really interesting use case for a local model.
The writing might be a bit mediocre but it would capture all the information.
Parent post really stumbled on a great idea here.