As someone with access to both Japanese ofuro and sauna, they are quite different in some respects. And similar in others. One thing which a sauna could do for me when the ofuro could not, was to fix a problem I had with coughing. Something which plauged me for a long time, and which the doctors couldn't find any reason for, but I had such painful daily coughs that it really bothered me. Couldn't sleep on my back either. Then I noticed that if I used the sauna daily, and carefully breathed hot air, the symptoms lessened. And after going for the daily sauna regime (instead of occasionally) for some time, the coughing problem I had for years finally disappeared. The hot baths did nothing for this (but was good for other things, e.g. muscle pains. And essential for being able to sleep at cold winter nights in non-insulated Japanese homes.. heating up the body with a very long very hot bath does wonders)
David Roche, a notable running coach (and runner), and his co-coaching wife (and runner) Dr. Megan Roche (MD/PhD) seem to think that hot tubs need to be at least 106F to generate much of a heat shock response, which is normally what one is looking for in the context of post-exercise heat exposure. I should note, however, that they are mostly reading the same research papers as everybody else, not doing primary studies themselves.
Being that the recommended max temperature for hot tubs is 104F that could be an issue. Hot tubs are definitely more pleasurable than saunas, and if it comes "close enough" I'd be fine with that.
As someone with access to both Japanese ofuro and sauna, they are quite different in some respects. And similar in others. One thing which a sauna could do for me when the ofuro could not, was to fix a problem I had with coughing. Something which plauged me for a long time, and which the doctors couldn't find any reason for, but I had such painful daily coughs that it really bothered me. Couldn't sleep on my back either. Then I noticed that if I used the sauna daily, and carefully breathed hot air, the symptoms lessened. And after going for the daily sauna regime (instead of occasionally) for some time, the coughing problem I had for years finally disappeared. The hot baths did nothing for this (but was good for other things, e.g. muscle pains. And essential for being able to sleep at cold winter nights in non-insulated Japanese homes.. heating up the body with a very long very hot bath does wonders)
Dr. Rhonda Patrick has been beating the drum for saunas for a long time, and she's reported that a hot tub can be equivalent or better: https://x.com/foundmyfitness/status/1955294334535995850?lang...
David Roche, a notable running coach (and runner), and his co-coaching wife (and runner) Dr. Megan Roche (MD/PhD) seem to think that hot tubs need to be at least 106F to generate much of a heat shock response, which is normally what one is looking for in the context of post-exercise heat exposure. I should note, however, that they are mostly reading the same research papers as everybody else, not doing primary studies themselves.
Being that the recommended max temperature for hot tubs is 104F that could be an issue. Hot tubs are definitely more pleasurable than saunas, and if it comes "close enough" I'd be fine with that.