Comment by WarmWash
13 days ago
But there is a very good chance that is what intelligence is.
Nobody knows what they are saying either, the brain is just (some form) of a neural net that produces output which we claim as our own. In fact most people go their entire life without noticing this. The words I am typing right now are just as mysterious to me as the words that pop on screen when an LLM is outputting.
I feel confident enough to disregard duelists (people who believe in brain magic), that it only leaves a neural net architecture as the explanation for intelligence, and the only two tools that that neural net can have is deterministic and random processes. The same ingredients that all software/hardware has to work with.
> I feel confident enough to disregard duelists
I'm a dualist, but I promise no to duel you :) We might just have some elementary disagreements, then. I feel like I'm pretty confident in my position, but I do know most philosophers generally aren't dualists (though there's been a resurgence since Chalmers).
> the brain is just (some form) of a neural net that produces output
We have no idea how our brain functions, so I think claiming it's "like X" or "like Y" is reaching.
Again, unless you are a dualist, we can put comfortable bounds on what the brain is. We know it's made from neurons linked together. We know it uses mediators and signals. We know it converts inputs to outputs. We know it can only be using deterministic and random processes.
We don't know the architecture or algorithms, but we know it abides by physics and through that know it also abides by computational theory.
https://www.dictionary.com/browse/duelist
1 reply →
Most people under 40 probably won't grok this unless they have practiced something like mindfulness mediation.
Our brains just make words in the same way we catch a tune in our heads.
Then we are culturally conditioned to claim ownership over them and justify them post-hoc (i.e., the ego).
Brains invented this language to express their inner thoughts, it is made to fit our thoughts, it is very different from what LLM does with it they don't start with our inner thoughts and learning to express those it just learns to repeat what brains have expressed.