Comment by Nevermark

My point isn’t that anyone’s view is wrong. I can’t make that claim either.

I hate what Cook did.

I would be happy and open to anyone who can point out how Apple was supposed to handle the actual threat of major tariffs in their components and systems better than he did.

But simply asserting a counter factual, a plausible way it might have been better, isn’t that. What would Cook be expected to do with that?

But what?

Not dismissing that there was a better way. There must be. It’s very worthwhile figuring out, even as a counter factual. That’s how we all learn.l

Not judging anyone. My answer is just or even more weak! I have really thought about this too, and come up with nothing so far.

(I appreciate and take note that my comment didn’t communicate my point well enough. It’s important to recognize weak reasoning. But that wasn’t meant to discourage, or show a lack of respect for another person’s efforts. I want a better answer too.)