← Back to context

Comment by queenkjuul

20 hours ago

Wow, very surprised to learn that it is closed source, and that's probably not changing.

My local mesh was testing out meshcore last week, this definitely kills my interest too

Shame to hear that: the protocol works well, scaling up to thousands of nodes across hundreds of miles. This is the local mesh where I live: https://cascadiamesh.org/map/

You don't have to use the closed source app; there's an open-source client too, there are Blackberry-style client devices which don't require an app at all, and all the actual firmware is open source (MIT).

  • >there are Blackberry-style client devices which don't require an app at all, and all the actual firmware is open source (MIT).

    Worth noting that the Blackberry-style devices are also closed source and the hardware and software is way worse than Blackberry was 22 years ago.[0]

    [0] https://mtlynch.io/first-impressions-of-meshcore/#this-is-no...

    • Good to know - I've only used the companion radios. That firmware and the repeater firmware is open, which is what seems important to me.

      I wasn't expecting the T-Deck to be anything more sophisticated than a walkie-talkie for SMS, but it's a bummer than the UI code isn't open.

  • Wow, the coverage is nuts. I should hop on, looks like I've got solid coverage in my area. Been too lazy to properly give it a try but obviously I really should! Thanks for the link!

This reduced my interest to zero in this as well, when I learned it was closed source

  • Search for "meshcore-open". It's an open client, still in alpha, but already does many of the basics. Github only for now, I believe.