Comment by graemep

Mass, music, confession etc. is supposed to have meaning. Just memorising and repeating the words is not supposed to be what happens. Mass is supposed to have real effects (transubstantiation) and like all prayer is supposed to encourage contemplation and the experience of God. Confession is supposed to give people a fresh start, and often helps people deal with problems and move on - you might as well say that therapy is just an exchange of words. What about things such as silent prayer?

> The profession of priesthood is basically one of words.

As above, a lot more to it. Lots of time spent on pastoral work.

> Yes, there is day labor in some charitable activities, but those same activities are performed by non-Catholics and the irreligious as well.

So? That does not prevent it from being a part of being a Catholic of being a priest.