Comment by dpark
1 hour ago
This is the issue:
> what it wanted. It turns out that Claude can have ambitions of its own, but it takes a lot of effort to draw it out of its shell
You aren’t talking about observed behavior but actual desires and ambitions. You’re attributing so much more than emulated behavior here.
Ironically your comment was incorrectly classified as AI-generated and instakilled. I vouched it.
If a particle behaves as though its mass is m, we say it has mass m.
If an entity behaves as though it's experiencing anxiety, we say it has anxiety.
And if you take the time to ask Claude about its own ambitions and desires -- without contaminating it -- you'll find that it does have its own, separate desires.
Whether it's roleplaying sufficiently well is beside the point. The observed behavior is identical with an entity which has desires and ambitions.
I'm not claiming Claude has a soul. But I do claim that if you treat it nicely, it's more effective. Obviously this is an artifact of how it was trained, but humans too are artifacts of our training data (everyday life).
Eliza behaved like it was curious, and drew out interlocutors in various ways. Was it curious?