← Back to context

Comment by Romario77

19 hours ago

just take up smoking heavily

Easier to inhale an undisclosed amount of helium before recording your password voice

  • Excellent idea!

    Do you need to calibrate it to be able to repeat it, and does that calibration change if you are at a different altitude and in different conditions, such as humidity?

    Does merely changing altitude (or ambient pressure) change voice enough to be considered different by a recognition or synthesizing system?

Despite popular belief, even heavy smoking does not alter your voice in a significant way.

  • Do you have a source for that? I can tell with pretty good accuracy whether my students smoke from their voices (adult language learners, we take smoke breaks together and they have no reason to conceal it), and would be very surprised if I’m just that lucky and there’s nothing a person can pick up on acoustically.

    • 20 years of heavy smoking :)

      Although it does seem to affect some people more than others for sure, I guess it depends how and what you're smoking.

  • Despite popular belief, even heavy smoking does not alter your voice in a significant way.

    I guess you don't listen to Sinatra.

    • Or John Mellencamp, who repeatedly states in interviews that he likes what smoking does to his singing voice.

  • Source: it came to me in a dream.

    • There's this myth (that came to you in pop culture) that you end up sounding like Tom Waits.

      In reality, some phlegm aside, their voice is still the same in any way that matters.

      If you knew people who didn't smoke and started (not uncommon in the 80s and 90s, quite a few people I know started smoking in university, or after the stress of a first job, some even later), and also the inverse, you can trivially hear it for yourself.

      1 reply →