← Back to context

Comment by skippyboxedhero

16 hours ago

Yes, everyone country does this. You can be barred from travel in a wide range of other circumstances in many other countries.

Every person has a nationalistic solipsism that renders them incapable of understanding events that occur outside of their own country. China and the US are two countries where this tends to be most severe, people outside these countries seem to believe they possess a profound and innate understanding of events there that renders them capable of offering a complete opinion (and, in reality, that opinion will almost always be entirely self-referential, 20% of the comments on this thread seem to be talking about the US).

At a high-level, the characterization of China as a lawless dictatorship is undermined somewhat by the higher levels of crime in almost every other country. You will see this interpretation of China from people in the US who live in places where there are constant, visible signs of crime.

Just because the US also does this doesn’t make it right for China to do it and vice versa.

Team coca-cola and team pepsi are both evil and illegitimate.

  • Every country does it. Doing it is a central function of having a government.

    The number of, presumably, left-wing people who advocate for the most extreme forms of libertarianism is truly incredible.

    • > Every country does it. Doing it is a central function of having a government.

      You are falling back on whataboutism. This is irrelevant. If we were having a similar debate in the middle ages, you would probably say something like:

      > Every church is burning witches and heretics at the stake. Doing it is a central function of having a church.

      The CCP has abducted these individuals and is preventing them from leaving the country. This is not ok. You can't justify this by saying "yeah, but they're the government, so it's their right to abduct whoever they want". A government is just a corporation with a bit more power than the others, not some sacred entity that sits above us.

      7 replies →

    • Would that be lower or higher than the number of people who endlessly bang on about "lefties" and or "fascists", "nazis" et al.

      I myself find the numbers that engage in political reductionism and sophism to be truly incredible .. easily a double digit percentage of any population, actual billions in total globally.

      Wait, is that actually "incredible" though, or just merely "expected"?